Meal Delivery For Seniors vs. Senior Home Care vs. Personal Chefs: An Honest Comparison

Author

Chefs for Seniors Southwest Florida

Posted on

Nov 22, 2021

Book/Edition

Florida - Sarasota, Bradenton & Charlotte Counties , Florida - Southwest

Share This

Finding the right meal service for seniors can be a challenge with so many options out there. A family caregiver who recently contacted us at Chefs For Seniors stated in an email:
My mom is no longer cooking for herself, and her health is suffering as a result. Somethings got to change, but Im not sure which option would work best for her. She currently has a CNA coming into the home every day for a few hours, but she doesnt know how to prepare diabetic-friendly meals.

Weve also tried some meal delivery companies, some better than others, but none seemed to stick. Then we found your company on Google, but a personal chef service seems like it would be way too expensive. What would be really nice is some kind of unbiased information about food options for seniors, do you know where I could find that?
This article is our attempt to answer her question and provide an unbiased comparison of meal delivery for seniors vs. senior home care meals vs. personal chef services.
Well list the advantages and disadvantages of each type of service, then allow you to form your own opinion on which meal service option would suit your needs best.

Meal delivery vs. home care vs. personal chef
Meal delivery services are convenient and affordable but can't be customized and sometimes aren't very healthy. Having a home care aide prepare meals can be a great source for companionship and the meals are freshly made, but senior caregivers arent trained cooks and services are very expensive. Personal chef services provide the highest quality fully customized meals but can be a slightly more expensive option than meal delivery.

Pros & Cons of Meal Delivery Services for Seniors

Affordable
Convenient
Calorie counts
Availability



Affordable
Compared to the other meal options for seniors examined in this article, meal delivery services tend to be more affordable. Most delivery services charge somewhere between $8-$14/meal plus shipping cost (usually '$20/order).
Convenient
Most meal delivery services for services have the option to order meals online, and a cooler full of frozen meals will be delivered to your door 3-7 days later. The meals can then be reheated at your convenience.
Calorie Counts
Since the meals are prepared in a factory setting, meal delivery companies can provide exact calorie counts and other nutrient breakdowns which can be helpful if you have certain dietary concerns.
Availability
Since the meals are prepared in a central location and shipped, you can order meals for delivery from anywhere in the US even if you live in a rural area.

Cons of Meal Delivery Services for Seniors
No customization
Quality
No accountability
More potential trash
No Customization

Many seniors have specific dietary concerns and/or food preferences, but unfortunately meal delivery services cannot accommodate your specific needs since the meals are mass-produced.
Quality
Most meal delivery services for seniors will deliver a cooler of mass-produce IQF frozen meals, so the meals arent as fresh and tasty as the other options examined in this article.
No Accountability
Many family caregivers are concerned about whether their loved ones are actually eating the meals ordered from a meal delivery service, or just stacking them in the freezer.
More Potential Trash
Environmentalists have noted that meal delivery services can lead to a lot of excess waste since the containers are disposable and thrown away after use.

Pros & Cons of Home Care Aid Meals
Companionship
Plated meals
Grocery store trip

Companionship
A senior home care aid prepares meals in the clients home, which offers a great opportunity for companionship. Recent studies have shown loneliness to be as dangerous to your health as smoking a pack of cigarettes a day.
Plated Meals
Senior home care aides aren't typically preparing make-ahead meals for the week. They're usually preparing one meal at a time and plating it for the client.
Grocery Shopping Trip
Many senior home care aids will bring the client along for a grocery-shopping trip, so they can pick out exactly what ingredients they'd like.

Cons of Home Care Aid Meals
Cost
Quality
Food Safety

Cost
Of the 3 options examined in this article, seniors home care aids preparing meals is by far the highest cost option. The average hourly rate for home care in the US is $25/hour, and if you had a home care aide prepare 2 meals/day at 1 hour prep time/meal, that adds up to $350/week plus groceries.
Quality
Since most caregivers don't have much cooking experience outside of possibly being a home cook, the quality of the food isnt always great and diets theyre able to accommodate can be limited.

Food Safety
Senior home care aides are not SERV Safe certified, so they are not trained in proper food preparation and storage procedures. This could lead to potential food safety issues.

Pros & Cons of Personal Chef Services
Quality
Customization
Companionship
Food Safety


Quality
Since many personal chefs have decades of cooking experience, the quality and freshness of the meals they prepare exceed the other two options examined in this article.
Customization
Personal chefs can customize meals to meet your specific dietary concerns and food preferences. They can even work with your dietitian and/or doctor to ensure youre eating what youre supposed to.
Companionship
Since personal chefs prepare the meals in your home, it provides a great opportunity for companionship and a fun experience.
Safety
All personal chefs are SERV Safe certified, so they're knowledgeable about proper food handling and storage procedures. This helps avoid the potential for foodborne illness.

Cons of Personal Chef Services
Cost
Availability
Lack of nutrition info


Cost
While many personal chef services are more affordable than you'd think, they're still usually more expensive than meal delivery services. For example, Chefs For Seniors charges $110-$140 (plus $40-$60 in groceries) for a weeks' worth of meals, '12 servings.
Availability
Since the personal chef industry is relatively new, services aren't available in every part of the US. Most personal chefs are located in and around major metropolitan areas.
Lack of Nutrition Info
Since the meals are made from scratch in your home, personal chefs aren't able to provide exact calorie counts and nutrition breakdowns for your meals.

Key Takeaways
Each of the three types of services examined in this article comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

Pros and Cons of Meal Delivery Services For Seniors
Meal delivery services are affordable and available throughout the US, but food quality is often lacking and meals cannot be customized for specific diets.

Pros and Cons of Home Care Aid Meal Prep
Having a senior home care aid prepare meals offers a great opportunity for companionship and meals can be plated fresh, but most caregivers arent trained cooks, arent ServSafe certified, and its by far the most expensive meal service option for seniors.

Pros and Cons of Personal Chef Services

Personal chef services can customize meals for specific diets/food preferences, all chefs are ServSafe certified, and the quality of the meals is top-notch. However, its a more expensive option than meal delivery services.
Still have questions about these three types of meal service options for seniors? Contact us!

Other Articles You May Like

Top 10 Inspiring Leaders of 2024 : Susan Nimnuan

A Guide to Helping Your Parents Navigate Aging

This comprehensive checklist helps families prepare for their parents' senior years, covering health, safety, legal, financial, and social aspects. Creating a senior life plan for aging parents is crucial for their wellbeing and peace of mind. It starts with early communication to discuss a seniors needs and preferences, considering a caregiving plan, health and medical care planning, safety and living arrangements that include developing an emergency plan. Financial discussions, managing finances without infringing on a seniors privacy. Legal documentation and insurance reviews ensure all legal matters are in order and insurance policies are adequate and current.Contact an Office in Your AreaWere so used to our parents living independently that we dont always notice when they begin to struggle with handling daily activities. Changes can begin gradually as they start to slow down, or they can happen quickly, when a parent has an unexpected diagnosis or accident. No matter if you live across town or across the country, proactively creating a senior life plan for your parents will give you peace of mind and allow them to continue to live their lives to the fullest.  Communication Approaching aging parents about planning their senior years can be a touchy subject for everyone involved. As a general rule, it is recommended to start having these conversations by the time youre in your forties, or theyre in their seventies (known as the 40-70 rule). Of course, you know your parents' habits and personalities best, so you are the best judge of their physical and mental health. Here are some factors that can determine the appropriate time to initiate this conversation:Start the conversation early, using the 40-70 rule, so you have time to make or change plans based on your parents' needsCreate a comfortable and open environment for the conversationPlan more than one conversation so you can cover all possible issuesTake notes so you remember what was discussed and can keep track of next stepsKeep a list of all their passwords for accounts such as computer, email, phone, and cable Create a Caregiving Plan A caregiving plan will ensure everyone is on the same page about the care needed and how it will be handled as your parents age. If they require additional care, consider how you can support their needs. This might involve coordinating with local caregivers, hiring professionals to assist with certain tasks, or, if you dont live nearby, planning regular visits to spend time with them.Have a caregiving plan ready in case your loved ones need in-home careDiscuss changes to your parents healthcare needs with their doctors Research different caregiving optionsFind out if your loved one has any specific needs to maintain their health and happiness  Health and Medical CareA senior life plan starts with understanding your parents health statuses and medical needs. When they are in excellent health, its essential that their care and treatment preferences are detailed in a living will or advanced directive and discussed with family members. Have this conversation now, during the planning stage, rather than during a medical emergency.Designate a healthcare proxy who can speak with doctors on your loved ones behalf and make healthcare decisions, especially if they are hospitalizedKeep a list of their medications up to date, including prescriptions, over-the-counter medications, supplements, and vitaminsKeep a list of your parent's doctors and specialists, including their contact information Ensure they are following their doctors advice and taking medications as prescribedMake a note of the closest urgent care facility and hospitalGet to know their primary care physicians Discuss your parents latest check-ups and help schedule upcoming appointments Encourage your parent to write a living will or advanced directive and keep a copy on file Safety and Living ArrangementsMost seniors want to remain in their homes as they age, connected to family, friends, and community. If your parents are able to continue living at home, consider home remodeling options to help them safely age in place. In addition, develop an emergency plan with your parents and make sure they know what to do in case of a natural disaster or other emergency.Evaluate the safety of their home and make modifications if necessaryReview any mortgage or financial concerns about the homeCheck in regularly, either in person, or by phone or video chatConsider long-term care insurance in case long-term care is ever requiredDevelop an emergency plan and list of emergency contacts Social and Support NetworkA strong social support network helps keep seniors healthy and active and gives them a sense of connection, belonging, and purpose. This support can include neighbors, friends, or other family members who can assist your loved one if needed. If possible, foster connections with their support network to have reliable contacts in case of emergencies.Encourage your parents to stay socially engaged and participate in activities that bring them joyCheck if your parents have a support network in their local communityKeep the name and number of a neighbor who can regularly check on your loved onesCreate a schedule of friends and family who call or regularly video chatEnsure your parents have access to reliable transportation when needed, especially if they dont drive Review FinancesDiscussing finances can be tricky. Seniors sometimes want to keep their financial information private, even from family members. Reassure them that they can keep exact dollar amounts confidential, but make sure you have access to the information if you need it. Have them assign a Durable Power of Attorney (POA) to someone who can make financial decisions on their behalf. When going over how your parents would like their finances handled, topics to discuss include outstanding debts, homeownership, savings, and retirement funds.Find out what financial accounts are open and where they are held Make a list of advisors contact information Ensure they are making informed decisions about retirement, investments, and insuranceStay up to date on Social Security benefits Check that beneficiary designations are currentMake sure your loved ones have a POA representativeStreamline bill paying by setting up automatic payments Ensure they know how to avoid scams Gather Legal Documents Discussing and taking care of legal issues while your parents enjoy good health can ensure everything is planned and understood. Make sure you know where your parents keep their personal information and important documents in case you need them. Go over everything together and meet with their estate planner so you can ask questions about their wishes and how to ensure they are carried out.Discuss important documents and where they are storedFind out if your parents have a will and a living will, and where they are locatedMake sure their POA for finances and healthcare proxies are in orderRead through their estate plan/will to make sure beneficiaries and responsibilities are correct and up to date Review Insurance PlansRegularly review your parents insurance policies. Its essential to know if their policies are adequate, up to date, and where the accounts are located. This information can help avoid undue financial burdens during medical emergencies or accidents. Make a list of active insurance policies such as auto, home, health, long-term care, etc.Review homeowners, auto, and life insurance policies to ensure they are adequate and up to dateReview health insurance coverage for any policy changes that need to be made based on current or future needs Aging Parents Checklist Although caring for an aging parent often means taking on financial, legal, and other responsibilities, it can also be a time to reflect on happy memories and plan for a future that includes more joyful moments. The aging parent checklist below can help you ensure youve got all the bases covered when it comes to life planning and the next steps for your aging loved ones.  CommunicationHave the conversation early so you have time to make or change plans based on your parents' needsCreate a comfortable and open environment for the conversationTake notes so you remember what was discussed and keep track of your next stepsKeep a list of all their passwords for accounts such as computer, email, phone, and cableHealth and Medical Care Designate a healthcare proxy who can speak with your loved ones doctors and make decisionsKeep an up-to-date list of all their medications, including over-the-counter, supplements, and vitaminsKeep a list of their doctors and specialists, including their contact information Ensure they are taking medications as prescribedMake a note of the closest urgent care facility and hospitalGet to know their primary care physicians Help schedule upcoming appointments Encourage your parent to write a living will and keep a copy on fileEnsure Safe Living ArrangementsEvaluate the safety of their home and make modifications if necessaryReview any mortgage or financial concerns about the homeCheck in regularly, either in person, or by phone or video chatConsider buying long-term care insuranceDevelop an emergency plan and list of emergency contacts in case of a natural disaster or other emergencyCreate a Caregiving PlanHave a caregiving plan ready in case your loved ones need in-home careDiscuss changes to your parents healthcare needs with their doctors Research different caregiving optionsFind out if your loved ones have any specific needs to maintain their health and happiness Social and Support Network Encourage your parents to stay socially engaged and participate in activities that bring them joyCheck if your parents have a support network in their local communityKeep the name and number of a neighbor who can regularly check on your loved onesCreate a schedule of friends and family who call or regularly video chatEnsure your parents have access to reliable transportation when needed, especially if they dont driveReview FinancesFind out what financial accounts are open and where they are held Make a list of advisors contact information Ensure they are making informed decisions about retirement, investments, and insuranceStay up to date on Social Security benefits Check that beneficiary designations are currentMake sure your loved ones have a POA representativeStreamline bill paying by setting up automatic payments Ensure they know how to avoid scamsGather Legal Documents  Discuss important documents and where they are storedFind out if your parents have a will and living will, and where they are locatedMake sure their POA for finances and healthcare proxies are in orderRead through their estate plan/will to make sure beneficiaries and responsibilities are correct and up to dateReview Insurance PlansMake a list of active insurance policies such as auto, home, health, long-term care, etc. Review homeowners, auto, and life insurance policies to ensure they are adequate and up to dateReview health insurance coverage regularly for any policy changes that need to be made as needs change

Kitchen Gadgets for Seniors: Making Cooking Easier and Safer

In this article, we explore a range of innovative kitchen gadgets that can make cooking easier, safer, and more accessible for seniors, empowering them to continue preparing their favorite meals at home with joy and confidence. By embracing these innovative tools, our senior loved ones can maintain their independence and bring joy to each day, continuing to prepare delicious meals with ease.Contact an Office in Your AreaAs we age, simple tasks like cooking can become more challenging. However, with the advancements in technology and the availability of kitchen gadgets designed specifically for seniors, cooking can continue to be enjoyable and hassle-free. Cooking at home allows seniors to control the ingredients and portion sizes, which can positively impact their health and nutrition. Additionally, seniors often have specific dietary requirements or restrictions, and preparing meals at home allows them to choose healthier options, control the amount of salt, sugar, and fat in their meals, and incorporate various nutritious ingredients.In this article, we explore a range of innovative kitchen gadgets that can make cooking easier, safer, and more accessible for seniors, empowering them to continue preparing their favorite meals at home with joy and confidence.Ergonomic UtensilsFor seniors with arthritis or reduced dexterity, traditional kitchen utensils can become difficult to handle. Ergonomic utensils are designed with user-friendly features such as comfortable grips, larger handles, and lightweight materials, making them easier to hold and maneuver. These utensils can include knives, peelers, spatulas, and ladles, all tailored to minimize strain on the hands and joints. Ergonomic utensils are practical and help reduce the risk of accidents in one of our favorite rooms in the home, the kitchen. Automatic Can OpenersOpening cans can be challenging at any age, especially for seniors with weakened grip strength or limited hand mobility. Automatic can openers are simple to operate and require minimal effort. These devices can safely and efficiently open cans, eliminating manual twisting or gripping. Some models even feature hands-free operation, where the can opener attaches to the lid and does all the work with the push of a button. Automatic can openers are easy to find and valuable to any senior's kitchen, providing convenience and helping senior loved ones stay independent. Easy-to-Read Digital ScalesAccurate measuring is crucial in cooking and specialty baking, but reading small print on traditional measuring scales can be challenging for seniors. Easy-to-read digital scales feature large, high-contrast displays with clear numerical values, making it easier for seniors to measure ingredients accurately. These scales often come with additional features such as tare function (resetting to zero after placing a container), unit conversion, and weight-locking capabilities. With digital scales, seniors can follow recipes with precision and achieve consistent results in their culinary endeavors. Best of all, Grandma's favorite cookies will continue to be the delicious treat we all remember! Safety Induction CooktopsTraditional stovetops can pose safety risks for seniors, including burns and accidental fires. Safety induction cooktops offer a solution by utilizing electromagnetic fields to generate heat directly in the cookware rather than on the surface. These cooktops remain cool to the touch, reducing the risk of burns. Additionally, they have built-in safety features such as automatic shut-off timers, temperature controls, and pan detection, ensuring that the cooktop turns off when the cookware is removed. Safety induction cooktops provide seniors a safer cooking alternative without compromising performance or versatility. Incorporating kitchen gadgets tailored for seniors can significantly enhance their cooking experience, making it safer, more convenient, and more enjoyable. From ergonomic utensils to automatic can openers, easy-to-read digital scales, and safety induction cooktops, these gadgets are designed to address seniors' specific challenges in the kitchen. By embracing these innovative tools, our senior loved ones can maintain their independence and bring joy to each day, continuing to prepare delicious meals with ease. Comfort Keepers Can HelpOur caregivers, who we call Comfort Keepers, can help seniors prepare meals, stick to an exercise plan, and provide transportation to preventive care and other doctors visits. Friendly, consistent support can help seniors make healthy changes in their livesand make it fun at the same time. Our Comfort Keepers give seniors the encouragement they need to remain healthy, happy, and engaged in activities they love every day.